The approval of articles involves the following steps. A summary table at the end shows the approximate timeframes for each stage of the evaluation process, from submission to final acceptance of the manuscript.
Editorial Team. For the purposes of this Procedure, the LAJED Editorial Team consists of the Editor and the Assistant Editor, who participate in the management, evaluation, and monitoring of the editorial process. Editorial decisions are adopted within this Editorial Team and, when formal communication is required, are formalized by the Editor in accordance with the journal procedures.
- Submission preparation. - Prior to submission, the author prepares the manuscript taking into account the journal submission checklist, including the Good Practices Commitment duly completed (Sections A to E) and signed.
- Submission. - The manuscript must be formally submitted through the LAJED OJS platform, following author registration. Exceptionally, when technical problems temporarily prevent completion of the submission through the platform, the manuscript and the required documentation may be sent to lajed@ucb.edu.bo. Once the issue has been resolved, the author must complete registration and formal submission in OJS before the editorial process can continue.
- Integrity check. - The Editorial Team will verify that the Good Practices Commitment has been duly completed and signed, including the declarations on conflicts of interest, use of generative artificial intelligence, data availability, and ethical oversight. LAJED will also use Turnitin as an auxiliary similarity-detection tool. The similarity percentage does not, by itself, constitute evidence of plagiarism and will not be used as an automatic criterion for acceptance or rejection; the report will be assessed qualitatively by the Editorial Team in accordance with Section 6 of the Editorial Policy. Where appropriate, automated tools for detecting AI-generated content may be used only as auxiliary alert instruments, in accordance with Section 7 of the Editorial Policy.
- Pre-screening. - The Editorial Team will conduct a pre-screening of the manuscript, considering its thematic relevance; compliance with formal, structural, and length requirements; academic integrity; the results of auxiliary similarity tools and, where appropriate, tools for detecting AI-generated content; and, where applicable according to the type of article, methodological adequacy and consistency among the research question, methods used, results, and conclusions. The pre-screening may result in the manuscript advancing to internal peer review or in editorial rejection.
- Pre-screening results. - Within a maximum of two weeks, the journal will inform the author whether the manuscript has passed editorial pre-screening and will proceed to internal peer review, or whether it has been editorially rejected. The communication will state the main reasons for the decision. When the manuscript advances to peer review, an estimated schedule for the subsequent stages of the editorial process may be provided. A rejected manuscript may be resubmitted as a new submission only when the editorial decision indicates that the identified issues can be remedied.
- Internal and external peer review. - Manuscripts that pass editorial pre-screening enter double-blind peer review in accordance with the Peer Review Policy. Reviewer selection and eligibility, as well as reviewer obligations concerning confidentiality, conflicts of interest, and the use of artificial intelligence, are set out in the corresponding specific policies. Reviewers must comply with the confidentiality and artificial intelligence use requirements established in LAJED’s Publication Ethics and Good Practices Statement.
- Peer review results. - The internal reviewer issues a reasoned recommendation on whether the manuscript should continue in the editorial process. The external reviewer issues a reasoned recommendation of acceptance without revisions, acceptance with revisions, or rejection. Reviewer recommendations are inputs to the editorial decision and do not replace the final decision of the Editorial Team.
- Communication of the peer review result. - The editorial decision, formalized by the Editor, together with the relevant comments arising from the peer review process, will be communicated to the author through LAJED’s official channels. Authors may submit a reasoned written appeal in accordance with the Publication Ethics and Good Practices Statement.
- Submission of revisions. - When the editorial decision is acceptance with revisions, the author will, as a general rule, have two weeks to submit the revised version and a response to the comments received. The deadline may be extended when justified by the nature or extent of the requested revisions.
- Review of revisions. - Upon receipt of the revised version, the Editorial Team will verify compliance with the requested revisions and the author’s response. When the changes are substantial or technical doubts remain, the manuscript may be sent back to the corresponding reviewer for a new evaluation. Lack of a response from the reviewer will not be interpreted as automatic approval of the revisions.
- Acceptance of the manuscript. - Once satisfactory compliance with the requirements and requested revisions has been verified, the Editorial Team will adopt the final editorial decision of acceptance. This decision will be formalized by the Editor and communicated to the author through LAJED’s official channels. The date of that communication will constitute the manuscript acceptance date. Assignment to an issue and the publication date will be subject to the editorial calendar and availability in the corresponding issue and will be recorded on the editorial platform.
Estimated Timeframes
| Code (*) | Procedures | Activity | Duration |
|---|---|---|---|
| A.1 | 2, 3, 4 and 5 | Submission, integrity checks, pre-screening, and communication of the result | 2 weeks |
| B.1 | 6 and 7 | Internal and external peer review | 2 months |
| B.2 | 8 | Communication of the evaluation result | 1 week |
| C.1 | 9 | Submission of revisions | 2 weeks, extendable where appropriate |
| C.2 | 10 | Review of revisions | 10 days |
| C.3 | 11 | Final editorial decision | 1 week |
| Estimated duration of the editorial process | Approximately 16-18 weeks | ||
- Estimated duration of the editorial process: approximately 16-18 weeks, subject to reviewer availability, the extent of the requested revisions, and other justified circumstances of the editorial process.
(*) Note: Activities (A) - For all authors with manuscripts received and submitted to integrity checks and pre-screening. Activities (B) - For all authors notified that their manuscripts passed editorial pre-screening and were sent to internal peer review and, where appropriate, external peer review. Activities (C) - For all authors with manuscripts conditionally accepted subject to revisions or at the final decision stage.
