Crafting co-governance: challenges of the long overdue Pesillo-Imbabura regional drinking water project in Ecuador
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35319/lajed.20223846Keywords:
Co-governance, community organization, drinking water, conflictAbstract
Co-governance of state and community organizations in drinking water provision is regarded as an effective and efficient way to achieve sustainable and inclusive water services. This study analyses the struggle over the management arrangement of the Pesillo-Imbabura regional drinking water project in the northern Sierra of Ecuador. It describes the troubled development of a large drinking water project, considering co-governance arrangements and effects on the autonomy, recognition, representation, and distributive outcomes for the (involved) communities. On paper, the institutional design was a good example of co-governance. In practice, the communities felt left out and envisioned much more control over the project. The communities that managed their own communal drinking water systems were marginalized in the Pesillo-Imbabura project by state policies for the execution of the project and the management of the new central water provision system. The government and donors overlooked the principle of hydraulic property creation which is important for the Indigenous communities because ensures Indigenous people control over their own identity. It establishes the direct link between the long struggle of the communities to get the project financed, the contribution to the construction of the infrastructure, and the creation of water use rights and obligations, but also the right to manage the system.
Downloads
References
Ackerman, J. (2004). Co-governance for accountability: Beyond “exit” and “voice”. World Development, 32(3), 447-463
Adams, E. A. and Zulu, L. C. (2015). Participants or customers in water governance? Community-public partnerships for peri-urban water supply. Geoforum, 65, 112-124.
Adams, E.A. and Boateng, G.O. (2018). Are urban informal communities capable of co-production? The influence of community–public partnerships on water access in Lilongwe, Malawi. Environment and Urbanization, 30(2),461-480.
Adams, E. A., Zulu, L. and Ouellette‐Kray, Q. (2020). Community water governance for urban water security in the Global South: Status, lessons, and prospects. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water, 7(5), e1466.
AGRIS (2008). Proyecto Regional de Agua Potable Pesillo-Imbabura. Universidad Central del Ecuador; Biblioteca Facultad de Ciencias Agrícolas.
Boelens, R., and Vos, J. (2014). Legal pluralism, hydraulic property creation and sustainability: the materialized nature of water rights in user-managed systems. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 11, 55-62.
Bovaird, T. (2007). Beyond engagement and participation: user and community coproduction of public services. Public Administration Review, 67(5), 846-860.
Campozano, L., Ballari, D., Montenegro, M. and Avilés, A. (2020). Future Meteorological Droughts in Ecuador: Decreasing Trends and Associated Spatio-Temporal Features Derived from CMIP5 Models. Front. Earth Sci., 8,1-17.
Cipriani, E., Molinero Ortiz, J., Jara-Negrete, E., Barrado, M., Arcos, C., Mafla, S., Custode, F., Vilaña, G., Carpintero, N. and Ochoa-Herrera, V. (2020). Heavy metal assessment in drinking waters of Ecuador: Quito, Ibarra, and Guayaquil. Journal of Water and Health, 18(6),1050-1064. doi: http://doi.org/10.2166/wh.2020.093
Domínguez-Castro, F., García-Herrera, R. and Vicente-Serrano, S.M. (2018). Wet and dry extremes in Quito (Ecuador) since the 17th century. Int. J. Climatol, 38(4), 2006-2014.
Dupuits, E. (2021). Desde la justicia hídrica al desarrollo verde. La coproducción de imaginarios sociotécnicos por movimientos comunitarios por el agua en Imbabura, Ecuador. European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies, (111), 19-37.
Dupuits, E., Baud, M., Boelens, R., De Castro, F. and Hogenboom, B. (2020). Scaling up but losing out? Water commons’ dilemmas between transnational movements and grassroots struggles in Latin America. Ecological Economics, 172, June 2020, 106625.
Dill, B. (2010). Public–public partnerships in Urban water provision: The case of Dar es Salaam. Journal of International Development, 22(5), 611-624.
Dunleavy, P., Margetts, H., Bastow, S. and Tinkler, J. (2006). New public management is dead—Long live digital-era governance. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 16(3), 467-494.
Eguren, F. (2017). Socialism in the Twenty-First Century and Neo-liberalism: Diverse Ideological Options Do Not Always Generate Different Effects. En G. Carbonnier, H. Campodónico and S. Tezanos Vázquez (eds.), International Development Policy, series N° 9, Geneva, Boston: Graduate Institute Publications, Brill-Nijhoff, (Chapter 6, pp. 103-127).
Fledderus, J., Brandsen T. and M. Honingh (2014). Restoring trust through the co-production of public services: a theoretical elaboration. Public Management Review, 16(3), 424-443.
Gobierno de Ecuador, INEN (Servicio Ecuatoriano de Normalización) (2014). Ecuadorian National Technical Norm NTE INEN 1108, 5th edn. http://www.pudeleco.com/files/a16057d.pdf
Gobierno de Ecuador, Registro Oficial (2016). Convenio de mancomunidad del proyecto de agua potable Pesillo-Imbabura. Quito, 18 de julio de 2016. Año IV N°. 638. http://mimzach.org.ec/index.php/biblioteca/ordenanzas/julio/palanda-2/37-ee638-20160718/file
Gobierno de Ecuador, SENAGUA (Secretaría del Agua) (2015). Proyecto regional de agua potable Pesillo-Imbabura. Consultoría Técnica Cía. Ltda. (Elaborated by Patricio Vargas, VIA, and ACP consultores). https://docplayer.es/55580382-Proyecto-regional-de-agua-potable-pesillo-imbabura.html#show_full_text
---------- (2019). Normativa que establece los parámetros técnicos para la evaluación y determinación de infracciones, sanciones y multas prescritas en la ley orgánica de recursos hídricos, usos y aprovechamiento del agua. Acuerdo N° 2018.0225. Edición especial.
Gobierno de Ecuador, MIDUVI (Ministerio de Desarrollo Urbano y Vivienda) (2013). Estudios definitivos del proyecto de agua potable-Imbabura estarán listos en septiembre. https://www.habitatyvivienda.gob.ec/
Hidalgo, J. P., Boelens, R. and Vos, J. (2017). De-colonizing water. Dispossession, water insecurity, and Indigenous claims for resources, authority, and territory. Water History 9(1), 67-85. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12685-016-0186-6
Hidalgo-Bastidas, J. P. and Boelens, R. (2019). The political construction and fixing of water overabundance: Rural–urban flood-risk politics in coastal Ecuador. Water International, 44(2), 169-187.
Hood, C. (2005). Public management: The Word, the movement, the science. In E. Ferlie, L. Lynn & C. Pollitt (Eds.), Oxford Handbook of Public Management. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Isham, J. and Kähkönen, S. (2002). Institutional determinants of the impact of communitybased water services: evidence from Sri Lanka and India. Economic development and cultural change, 50(3), 667-691.
Jiménez-Mendoza, S. and Terneus-Páez, F. (2019). Nexo agua-energía: análisis del flujo hídrico del Proyecto Hidroeléctrico Coca Codo Sinclair. Ingenius, (21), 53-62, enero-junio.
Johnson, C. and Osborne, S.P. (2003). Local strategic partnerships, neighbourhood renewal, and the limits to co-governance (2003). Public Money and Management, 23(3), 147-154.
Kennemore, A. and Weeks, G. (2011). Twenty‐first century socialism? The elusive search for a post‐neoliberal development model in Bolivia and Ecuador. Bulletin of Latin American Research, 30(3), 267-281.
Manosalvas, R., Hoogesteger, J. and Boelens, R. (2021). Contractual Reciprocity and the Re-Making of Community Hydrosocial Territories: The Case of La Chimba in the Ecuadorian paramos. Water, 13, 1600.
Martínez Valle, L. and Martínez Godoy, D. (2019). Territorial dynamics and social differentiation among peasants in the northern highlands of Ecuador. Journal of Agrarian Change, 19(4), 635-653.
McMillan, R., Spronk, S. and Caswell, C. (2014). Popular participation, equity, and co-production of water and sanitation services in Caracas, Venezuela, Water International, 39(2), 201-215.
Merino, R. (2016). An alternative to ‘alternative development’? Buen Vivir and human development in Andean countries, Oxford Development Studies, 44(3), 1-16.
Moreno, L., Pozo, M. and Vancraeynest, K. (2020). Integrating water-quality analysis in national household surveys: water and sanitation sector learnings of Ecuador. Clean Water, (3), 23.
Mutambara, S., Darkoh, M. B. and Atlhopheng, J. R. (2016). A comparative review of water management sustainability challenges in smallholder irrigation schemes in Africa and Asia. Agricultural Water Management, 17, 63-72.
Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the Commons. The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
---------- (1993), A communitarian approach to local governance. Nat Civic Rev, 82, 226-233. https://doi.org/10.1002/ncr.4100820305 (retrieved 20/09/2022)
---------- (1993). Design principles in long‐enduring irrigation institutions. Water Resources Research, 29(7), 1907-1912.
---------- (2008). Design principles of robust property-rights institutions: what have we learned. En G.K. Ingram y Y.H. Hong (Eds.), Property Rights and Land Policies (pp. 215-248). Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
Periódico Expectativa (14 de septiembre de 2018). “Delegación francesa y alcaldes evaluaron avance del proyecto Pesillo-Imbabura”. http://www.expectativa.ec/delegacion-francesa-y-alcaldes-evaluaron-avance-del-proyecto-pesillo-imbabura/
Perugachi, J.M. and Cachipuendo, C. (2020). La lucha por el agua: gestión comunitaria del proyecto de agua potable Pesillo-Imbabura. Publicación arbitrada de la Universidad Politécnica Salesiana. Quito: Editorial Abya-Yala.
Romano, S. T. (2017). Building capacities for sustainable water governance at the grassroots: “Organic empowerment” and its policy implications in Nicaragua. Society & Natural Resources, 30(4), 471-487.
Schwartz, K. (2006). Managing public water utilities: an assessment of bureaucratic and NPM models in the water supply and sanitation sectors in low- and middle-income countries. Rotterdam: Erasmus University.
SDGF (Sustainable Development Goals Fund) (2015). Governance in the water and sanitation sector in Ecuador within the framework of the Millennium Development Goals. Water Governance in Ecuador Case study. https://www.sdgfund.org/case-study/water-governance-ecuador
Serrano, S.M., Aguilar, E. and Martínez, R. (2017). The complex influence of ENSO on droughts in Ecuador. Clim Dyn, 48, 405-427.
Sillitoe, P. (Ed.) (2017). Indigenous Knowledge: Enhancing Its Contribution to Natural Resources Management. CABI.
Valladares, C. and Boelens, R. (2019). Mining for Mother Earth. Governmentalities, sacred waters, and nature’s rights in Ecuador. Geoforum, 100, 68-79.
Vos, J. and Vincent, L. (2011). Volumetric water control in a large-scale open canal irrigation system with many smallholders: The case of Chancay-Lambayeque in Peru. Agricultural Water Management, 98(4), 705-714.
Walnycki, A. (2017). Contesting and co-producing the right to water in peri-urban Cochabamba. In S. Bell, A. Allen, P. Hofmann and T-H Teh (Editors), Urban Water Trajectories, Springer, pp. 133-147.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Revista Latinoamericana de Desarrollo Económico
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
